A new steer08 December 2010
Could an innovative multi-axle steering system lead to renewed interest in longer, heavier vehicles (LHVs)? John Challen and Brian Tinham talk to the people behind the technology
Despite much debate, there has been little movement on the issue of longer, heavier vehicles (LHVs) in the UK. Even after hitting the headlines late last year when his 25.1m combination attempted to move onto UK roads, Dick Denby, chairman of Denby Transport, states that he has had little feedback from the DfT – which simply served him a prohibition notice.
Seems the UK is steadfastly resisting the temptation to dip its toe into multi-trailer waters. Meanwhile, trials are already underway in European countries, including France, Italy and parts of Scandinavia. And next year, Germany is also set to allow LHVs on its roads, under an evaluation programme organised by the federal government. More than 200 companies have registered an interest, including MAN (Transport Engineer, November 2010, p5).
On the face of it, the DfT's reluctance to move is very strange, given the potential benefits that LHVs could bring. Whether it be reduced congestion from fewer vehicles on the road, lower fuel and running costs as operators shrink their vehicle fleets, or reduced CO2 emissions, the advantages of running LHVs should be obvious.
That said, data from automotive consultancy CLEAR sheds some light on why enthusiasm for LHVs in this country might be lower than in others. Director Gary Beecroft estimates that, while eight European-style 40-tonne artics could be cut to just five LHVs, the number for UK-friendly 44-tonners drops by just one truck, to seven.
Those figures are based on a 40-tonne gvw truck offering a payload of 26 tonnes, while a UK-friendly 44-tonner provides 30 tonnes and a Scandinavian 60-tonne LHV fields a 42 tonne payload. Those figures are open to challenge, with others suggesting closer to 29 tonnes payload for a 44 tonner and 38 tonnes for a 60 tonner at 21.42 metres.
Additionally, they take no account of the vast majority of vehicle movements where cube, not ultimate payload, is the issue. Dick Denby states that two of his Eco-Link double trailers would replace three British standard artics on low density, high cube traffic, with space to spare. However, plainly, the argument for reduced vehicle and overhead costs is somewhat stronger in continental Europe than in the UK.
And then there's the political angle, which hinges on: public perception of increased noise and size from LHVs; concerns over potentially increased road damage; and issues surrounding safety – particularly due to swing-out of extended trailer rear ends on sharp bends, at roundabouts and during high-speed lane changes.
Hope for hauliers? But in the last couple of months there has been talk of developments that could yet lead to LHVs inching onto UK roads. First, the DfT's professor Brian Collins promised to release the results of a report into extending the length (but not the weight) of semi-trailers by 2.05m before the end of this year. Although hardly on the scale of European trials, such an increase in trailer length would go some way to achieving the costs and emissions benefits promised by LHVs.
Second, however, eight years of work on active trailer steering systems at the Cambridge Vehicle Dynamics Consortium (CVDC) is finally coming to fruition. As Professor David Cebon, who heads up the consortium at the University of Cambridge, puts it: "We have been running a big project on multiple axle steering of articulated tractor/semi-trailers and longer, heavier vehicles for some years. The technology has been proven and we are now ready for commercial development."
One of the key drivers behind CVDC's work – which also involves Volvo Trucks, ArvinMeritor, Goodyear, MIRA (the Nuneaton-based automotive engineering centre) and engineering design firm 3D Evolution – was a determination to deal with the fundamental problem for long trucks attempting to negotiate sharp bends. Cebon points to the problem with un-steered longer combinations of jack-knifing, as they attempt the standard 12.5m-diameter roundabout manoeuvring test. And he adds: "Conventional trailer steering systems just don't work very well: the back of the trailer needs to follow the fifth-wheel of the tractor unit, an approach called 'perfect path following'. But their path following performance is poor – with, for example, tail swing meaning that the trailer doesn't just go where the driver goes."
CVDC's objective, with its active trailer steering development, was to apply 'perfect path following' logic to B-doubles (tractor unit towing a lead trailer with a rear-mounted fifth-wheel, in turn towing another semi-trailer) and European modular system (EMS) vehicles in all scenarios – including high and low speed manoeuvres, as well as forward and reverse travel – always aiming to ensure that the entire combination steers itself predictably. And, following its success, LHVs can now be made much more manoeuvrable and significantly safer than conventional vehicles – and they can benefit from far lower tyre wear and 20–30% lower fuel consumption per freight task.
"One day, there may be a standard B-double in the UK," believes Cebon, "but at the moment, trucks of this length just can't get round one of our roundabout without jack-knifing. With this system, a dual-articulated B-double can beat a standard tractor-trailer combination easily."
Cebon agrees that when CVDC's project started, there was no known way of getting the steering right for extra length vehicles. "Similar sized combinations, such as that operated by Denby Transport (see panel) used a completely different, and more conventional, direct-acting steering system, so there was no obvious approach to doing better," he explains.
As it happens, previous experience with active roll control on tankers provided a background for some of the technology. "This was complex engineering and helped to create the only tilting trailer in the world, with the biggest anti-roll bar in the history of HGVs," he says. "There were four active anti-roll bars – on the tractor drive axle and all three semi-trailer axles – and 10 semi-active dampers. And all were connected via the vehicle's CANbus, using three networked computers."
That system reduced lateral transfer by 25%, but was deemed too expensive and heavy to be practical. It did, however, prove that stability could be improved through the intervention of active control. The next step was to turn that to steering control, developing both the computer algorithms, to control the vehicle, and the mechanical actuation system, to effect independent steering on each axle.
Today, CVDC's steering configuration is modular and detachable, with the hardware built onto the trailers themselves. Controlled via the CANbus network, the team's system allows all axles, except the tractor drive axle, to be steered. Electrical power comes from a 24V source, while hydraulic pumps drive the individual trailer steering axles. In terms of the hardware, hydraulic systems are used on earthmovers and construction equipment, reveals Cebon, but CVDC's system requires considerably greater computing power and feedback sensors.
How good is it? So good that, using a rear-facing camera and joystick mounted in the cab, a driver can even reverse a full length B-double safely down small side streets, round bends and up to a loading bay, without touching the truck steering wheel – and with the entire combination faithfully following the rear wheels. "The driver now has a vehicle that drives a bit like a car," comments Cebon. "He points the lead vehicle where he wants it to go and he knows that all of the other vehicle units will follow."
High-speed headaches What about high speeds, where the engineering problems are more about safety and stability? "Conventional semitrailer steering systems have to be locked at high speeds or they make the trailers unstable. Further, on existing multi-trailer vehicles, if you perform a sudden lane change, you get rearward amplification and the first trailer deviates slightly from its path, while the second deviates even further and is could be in danger of rolling over," explains the Cambridge man. "But by steering each axle along the vehicle quickly and using the correct control strategy, you can ensure that each vehicle unit faithfully follows the correct path – which also dramatically improves the stability of the whole combination."
How good is it? Cebon says that trials to date show that, whereas a conventional trailer rear end on an EMS vehicle swings out 1 metre on a 2.5 metre width lane change at 80kph, his trailers, equipped with individual steering and path following software, achieve zero oscillation. Simulation suggests that even on motorways, where lane widths are 3.65m, the oscillation would be less than 20cm (half a tyre width), compared with a standard unsteered tractor trailer combination, which swings out 1.3 metres. Also lateral accelerations and yaw are reduced by 18% and 46% respectively. "So this turns out to be a better way or achieving anti-roll than our earlier mechanical tipping trailer approach," adds Cebon.
While maintenance is a little further down the development line, Cebon assures technicians and fleet managers that standard technology and components will predominantly be used for production vehicles. "We've been working on a hardware setup where the whole system sits on a subframe. That allows you to bring in the bogie and bolt it straight on to an existing trailer or tractor unit. It you have a maintenance issue you can unbolt the bogie, put another one on, and be away," he explains.
But there are other approaches when it comes to volume production. For now, with the technology proven and already demonstrated working effectively with a Volvo tractor unit, the next hurdle is a business one. "Turning this into a commercially viable proposition for manufacturers is the next step. It could be tough, but we think it might be helped along by changing legislation," observes Cebon.
Denby Transport's steering
The most high-profile and often loudest voice in the demand for LHVs in the UK is Dick Denby, chairman of Denby Transport and associate member of CVDC. Developed eight years ago, the steering system on Denby's extended trailer combination may not be in the same league as CVDC's technology, but he reckons it still has a place on the road.
"The Australians and New Zealanders have been saying for years that, if you have multiple fulcrums, stability and safety dictates you need them as far away from each other as possible," comments Denby. "On rigid trucks with converter dollies, some can be as little as 4.5m from pin-to-pin, but they are trying to lengthen the drawbar arm to stretch that."
Denby says his B-double has a pin-to-pin length of 8.75m. As for the detail, his steering system comes from Breeman International Supplies, based in Rotterdam, which also supplies technology for long low-loaders.
"Instead of the trailer kingpin mounted traditionally, it is placed on a large turntable of its own, with a steel wedge, which mounts on the fifth-wheel plate of the tractor unit," explains Denby. "The pin turns with the tractor unit, not the semi-trailer," he says, adding that a potentiometer sensor on top of the fifth-wheel/wedge combo then measures the yaw angle.
"An onboard computer is alerted when the yaw angle reaches 3°," continues Denby. "It gets a further speed signal from another axle. If that speed is in excess of 40km/h nothing happens, because it is in failsafe mode, but between 15km/h and 40km/h maximum steer is available."
From a mechanical aspect, Denby explains that it is "similar to the steering on a twin-steer truck", with the hydraulic steering on the rear axle of the link trailer connected to the front axle, using serial arms. "We've licensed the technology to a Dutch company called Jumbo, and it is currently being used by a Dutch supermarket," he adds, remaining hopeful that further applications will be achieved in the near future.
John Challen and Brian Tinham
3D Evolution Ltd
Denby Transport Ltd
Goodyear Dunlop Tyres UK Ltd
Horiba MIRA Ltd
Volvo Group UK Ltd
This material is protected by MA Business copyright
See Terms and Conditions.
One-off usage is permitted but bulk copying is not.
For multiple copies
contact the sales team.