Power challenge 02 June 2015

When Power Electrics needed to rethink its eight-wheelers to accommodate larger loads, it turned to Imperial Commercials and Central Hydraulic Loaders to generate a solution. Brian Tinham reports

It's not every day that fleet engineers are called upon to think outside the box, and specify a custom truck for a new and challenging duty. Even less frequently does such a project involve pushing the boundaries to the limit, not only on weights and dimensions, but also manoeuvrability, payload potential, and crane and axle configurations. But that's exactly what Alex Harris, transport manager at national generator hire and sales specialist Power Electrics, came up against late last year.

Harris explains that, until a few months ago the Bristol-based firm was running a fleet including 17 Hiab-equipped trucks for its heavy work, mostly DAF six- and eight-wheeler rigids. Most were capable of handling the then flagship 500kVA FG Wilson diesel generator, which came in at 6.5 tonnes with fuel. Most had rear-mounted lorry loaders and were equipped for hauling tandem or tri-axle drawbar trailers with ancillaries and/or additional generators for customers – mostly utility companies, construction firms and organisers of sports events and festivals. It was an ideal mix, he says, established over many years for its ability to get large, heavy equipment into tight, sometimes inaccessible locations – such as substations in housing estates or down country lanes.

"Then late last year, FG Wilson launched their Tier 3 engined [Euro 6 equivalent for static plant] machine. We knew they were bigger and heavier, but hadn't realised they would come in at 7.6 tonnes," he recalls. That wasn't an immediate problem: Power Electrics had some eight-wheelers with 38—48 tonne-metre cranes man enough to lift the beasts, and space on the truck beds to carry them. But, being double-drive, they weren't hugely manoeuvrable. "Also, the cranes were working near capacity and, with the new generators substantially longer, there wasn't a lot of clearance between the trucks' front-mounted stabilisers and the rear Hiab outriggers when placing them on site. So we needed to think again."

Harris describes the new requirement as a 32-tonne rigid with: a bigger crane capable of lifting and placing the new generator; payload capacity and bed space for the same plus ancillaries, or combinations of smaller generators; and toolboxes for lifting gear, etc. The new truck also needed manoeuvrability close to matching its existing six-wheelers; it had be drawbar compatible; and it needed to facilitate transhipping of plant on-site. It was a big ask and he accepted from the outset that some compromises were inevitable.

"For example, it was always going to be fairly easy to design a truck that worked when loaded, but ensuring the rear axle wasn't overloaded when running empty was another matter," he states. "Also, we knew that at Euro 6, there wasn't going to be much space behind the cab for our preferred high-level exhaust stack – but we still needed reasonable ground clearance at N3 and space under the body for supplementary stabilisers."

Power Electrics turned to DAF Trucks' dealership Imperial Commercials, in Bristol, and PM Cranes' distributor and bodybuilder Central Hydraulic Loaders, in Tamworth. And what resulted, according to Imperial's sales manager Gary Woodruff, was a model collaborative design project that delivered on just about every criterion.

"We started by using our TOPEC [DAF's computer-aided design software] system with the new bodybuilder guidelines, which include the latest Euro 6 chassis technical drawings," says Woodruff. "Comparing those with Power Electrics' existing Euro 5 eight-wheelers, even on the nearest new Euro 6 equivalents there was less space for the exhaust package, and the cab size was a little different, too. Central Hydraulics then provided their recommended PM 53023 48 tonne-metre crane data, with weight and load space requirements, and it became clear that the truck bed length would have to be a little shorter while payload would be about a tonne down."

From then on, it was about working with body lengths, wheelbases, crane position, exhaust layout, etc, to hit the criteria and keep the axle loads legal whether laden or unladen. For example, if Power Electrics had stuck to its high-level exhaust requirement, the front headboard would have to be pushed back. To achieve the bed length, the crane would also need to shift rearwards – but that risked overloading the rear axles when the truck was unalden.

So the team then looked at a conventional exhaust. That solved the bed length and payload issues, but left inadequate space to accommodate the front stabilisers – necessary to complement the loader's own outriggers. One option was to raise the bed so the stabilisers could fit above the exhaust. However, that would necessitate heat shielding; there would be weight implications; and the bed would be too high for health and safety.

The solution: Central Hydraulics' Digby Scott suggested mounting tilted stabilisers, capable of squeezing in front of the headboard without compromising the bed length or the crane position. But that, in turn, required a compact, rigid subframe light enough to stay within the design parameters. Hence the choice of a box and cruciform structure fabricated from high grade steel – a choice proved by DAF's and PM Cranes' CAD systems.

What about that all-important manoeuvrability? Harris says the project team eventually settled on a DAF CF 460 FAX with a 6.4m wheelbase and 6.9m body, and equipped with a rear-steer axle. "That meant losing the double drive, but we have one MAN single-drive truck and it has never got stuck. Also, in recent years our customers' sites have increasingly become properly tracked, so double-drives are less critical. Frankly, it was a compromise we were prepared to take to get the turning circle we needed." And that was 5.88m inner radius – slightly better than Power Electrics' existing six wheelers.

Harris says that once the big picture had been nailed, there were just a few tweaks ahead of bodywork construction. "I went to Tamworth with our workshop foreman, partly to ensure that the truck, as specified, would meet National Small Series type approval and partly to check that the vehicle would be flexible enough for our operations," he explains. And he cites details such as the positioning of the toolboxes and operation of the side impact bars, the rear crash underrun protection and the drawbar hitch.

"We need large toolboxes for our lifting accessories, ratchet straps, etc. But while the drivers want them to be accessible, they're not impact rated so have to be protected by the side bars," he explains. That meant agreeing a mounting arrangement for them that wouldn't impact on type approval. And it was a similar story with the rear crash bars, which had to be fabricated from cylindrical section steel – so were specified with gas struts for easy lifting. As for the drawbar, the team settled on a VBG air-operated unit to simplify coupling for the driver, and improve health and safety.

Remarkably, in the end, DAF's and PM Cranes' CAD software disagreed by a mere 10kg payload. Imperial Commercials' theoretical figure (including chassis, fuel, driver, crane, body and the 7.6 tonne generator) was 20,684kg, while Central Hydraulic's estimate came in at 20,830kg. However, the latter had allowed for a revised tool box arrangement and a 130kg tow hitch.

The result: Power Electrics took delivery of its first new truck late in April, and a second is due for delivery as we go to press. More will probably follow. For Harris, this truck configuration is now the benchmark for the foreseeable future. "With this bed length, carrying flexibility, crane capacity and manoeuvrability, we can now use the new 32-tonner for all heavy contracts, whether we're carrying the new large machine or multiple smaller generators. There are thousands of potential combinations of equipment, but I am confident this new truck design will be up to them all."

Brian Tinham

Related Downloads

Related Companies
Central Hydraulic Loaders Ltd
DAF Trucks Ltd
FG Wilson
Imperial Commercials
MAN Truck & Bus UK Ltd
Power Electrics (Bristol) Ltd

This material is protected by MA Business copyright
See Terms and Conditions.
One-off usage is permitted but bulk copying is not.
For multiple copies contact the sales team.